Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council

Biblio File: Alt-Blight

YOU ARE IN: Home Page > Topics > Anti-Zionism

Ben Shapiro


(((Semitism))): Being Jewish in America in the Age of Trump
Jonathan Weisman, St. Martin's Press, March 2018, 256 pp., US$25.99


In September 2015, the New York Times ran a rather peculiar chart. It was designed to elucidate just why certain Democrats would or would not vote for President Obama's Iran nuclear deal - and it organised Democratic lawmakers by whether they were Jewish while noting how many Jews resided in their congressional districts. The word "Jewish" was highlighted in yellow. After brief but significant blowback online, the Times removed the "Jewish" indicator. The editor who supervised the chart's publication was Jonathan Weisman, deputy Washington editor for the newspaper.

Now, two years later, Weisman has published a book about antisemitism - and, more specifically, about the supposedly grave threat to Jews springing from the alt-right and the Trump Administration. (((Semitism))), for such is the book's title, suffers from two grave ills. First, Weisman believes that political leftism and Judaism are identical. Second, he knows little or nothing about the political right, in whose camp he places the alt-right movement. Combine these two shortcomings with a heavy dose of self-regard, and you get (((Semitism))): a toxic brew of anti-Israel sentiment, bagels-and-lox cultural Jewishness, and unbridled hostility toward mainstream conservatism, which he lumps together with despicable alt-right antisemitism.

According to Weisman, Judaism derives its present-day importance from the way it provides a religious echo to secular leftism. This is his actual opening sentence: "The Jew flourishes when borders come down, when boundaries blur, when walls are destroyed, not erected." Thus does he describe a people whose binding glue over the millennia is a faith tradition literally designed to separate its adherents from those who are not their co-religionists.

This ethnic-Jew-centric perspective leads Weisman to reject not merely Jewish observance, which he finds parochial and divisive, but the tie between Judaism and Israel, which he subtly titles "The Israel Deception." He laments: "The American Jewish obsession with Israel has taken our eyes off not only the politics of our own country, the growing gulf between rich and poor, and the rising tide of nationalism but also our own grounding in faith." He sneers at Jews who promote the "tried and true theme of the little Israeli David squaring off against the giant Arab Goliath."

Weisman believes, like John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt, that members of both parties are guilty of "kissing the ring" at AIPAC, of "turn[ing] to mush when the subject was Israel." In fact, Weisman says, the antisemitic BDS movement on college campuses "is worrisome as much for what it says about the American Jew's inextricable links to Israel as for what it says about anti-Semitism." In his view, "Barack Obama was the apotheosis of liberal internationalism... The Jew thrived."

Thus Weisman has this to say about his infamous Iran-deal chart: "I had my own brush with fratricidal Jew-on-Jew violence during that heated debate." Was Weisman attacked? Assaulted? No, he received some nasty notes in response to running a chart. Weisman says he found the uproar "absurd" and laments that he is "still hearing about it." Poor lamb.

Weisman gets it right when he writes about the mainstreaming of the alt-right - the winking and nodding from Breitbart News and Donald Trump himself, the willingness of many in the mainstream to reward alt-right popularisers like Milo Yiannopoulos. (I left Breitbart in March 2016 due to differences regarding our coverage of the presidential campaign). Weisman is at his best when describing the origins of the alt-right and their infiltration of more well-read outlets.

But he can't stop there. Instead, he seeks to impute the alt-right to the entire conservative movement and builds, Hillary Clinton-style, a fictitious basket of deplorables amounting to half the conservative movement. He cites "Christian fundamentalist" Israel supporters, to whom he wrongly attributes universally apocalyptic End of Times motivation. He condemns anti-immigration advocates, whose opposition to importation of un-vetted Muslim refugees he likens to antisemitic anti-immigrant movements of years past. He reviles "anti-feminists," those who oppose political correctness in video games, Republican Jewish Coalition members who laughed at Trump making a Jewish joke, and free-speech advocates supposedly engaged in "forcible seizure of the free-speech movement" (a weird charge to level, considering that it cost Berkeley US$600,000 to prevent Antifa from burning down the campus when I visited).

In other words, pretty much anyone who didn't vote for Hillary Clinton gets smeared with the alt-right brush, outside of those specifically targeted by the alt-right.

The problem of alt-right antisemitism, Weisman thinks, is just a problem of anti-leftism. If we could all just give money to the notoriously left-wing propaganda-pushing Southern Poverty Law Center, watch Trump-referential productions of Eugene Ionesco's Rhinoceros at the Edinburgh National Festival (yes, this is in the book, and no, it is not parody), ignore antisemitic attacks at the Chicago Dyke March (I am not making this up), slap some vinyl signs on synagogues (no, I am still not making this up), and "not get too self-congratulatory" (seriously, guys, this is all real), all will be well. In the end, Weisman's goal is to build a coalition of ethnic and political groups, cobbled together in common cause against conservatives - conservatives, he says, who represent the alt-right support base.

As the alt-right's chief journalistic target in 2016, I'm always happy to see them clubbed like a baby seal. And there is a good book to be written about the alt-right. At times, Weisman borders on it, particularly when he seeks to investigate the bizarre relationship between Trump and the trolls who worship him.

But Weisman's ardent allegiance to leftism leads him to misdiagnose the problem, to ignore the rising antisemitism of his own side (the DNC nearly elected antisemite Keith Ellison its leader last year), to prescribe the wrong solutions, and, most of all, to react in knee-jerk fashion to the alt-right by flattering himself as the epitome of everything the alt-right hates. Thin as the paper it was printed on, (((Semitism))) is a failure of imagination.

Ben Shapiro is Editor-in-Chief of The Daily Wire and host of "The Ben Shapiro Show," the top conservative podcast in the USA. Shapiro is the author of seven non-fiction books, including the New York Times bestseller Bullies: How the Left's Culture of Fear and Intimidation Silences America (Simon & Schuster, 2012). © Commentary Magazine (, reprinted by permission, all rights reserved.


Most recent items in: Anti-Zionism